Week 11 kicks off with an AFC South rivalry matchup between the second-place Texans and the third-place Colts. Both teams arrive at the Thursday Night Football spot with just three wins this season and meet for the second and final time, with Indianapolis having come out on top in Week 3. The Colts ended a five-game losing streak on Sunday with a 24-22 win over the Dolphins but arrive as heavy road underdogs against their division rivals.
Here are the players worth targeting in your DFS lineups for Thursday night’s AFC South showdown. Be sure to check out our NFL betting trends page for data and odds on every game.
Colts vs. Texans DFS Picks
| Pos | Player | Matchup | FPPG | Salary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MVP | 👑C.J. Stroud |
IND @ HOU | 22.4 | $15,000 |
| FLEX | ![]() David Montgomery |
IND @ HOU | 9.1 | $8,200 |
| FLEX | ![]() Seth McGowan |
IND @ HOU | 4.6 | $4,600 |
| FLEX | ![]() Xavier Hutchinson |
IND @ HOU | 9.1 | $6,200 |
| FLEX | ![]() Texans |
IND @ HOU | 6.2 | $5,800 |
| FLEX | ![]() Nico Collins |
IND @ HOU | 17.0 | $10,200 |
C.J. Stroud, HOU/QB/MVP ($15,000)
While you would not guess it from the record, Houston QB C.J. Stroud has had a tremendous fourth season after regressing following a strong rookie year. The 25-year-old enters Thursday ranked third in passing yards per game at 273.56 and has limited turnovers with a 19:3 TD-to-INT ratio. He has been in exceptional form lately, throwing 13 TDs across his last four games alone. He will now look to rectify one of his quietest performances of the season, when he faced Indianapolis back in Week 3.
Stroud finished that contest with just 167 passing yards and 1 TD, never finding a rhythm. The Colts defense has regressed a lot since then, and the lack of a consistent pass rush since trading away DT DeForest Buckner should help Stroud settle in this time around. Indianapolis is conceding the sixth-most passing yards in the league and will be without DB Charvarius Ward and potentially DB Sauce Gardner as well. With Stroud’s recent form and the injuries in an already struggling secondary, the fourth-year QB is set up for a breakout in primetime against his division rivals.
David Montgomery, HOU/RB ($8,200)
Veteran RB David Montgomery has had an up-and-down season but steps into the lead role this week with fellow RB Woody Marks ruled out. Montgomery has missed the last four games, though all signs point to him playing Thursday after a full week of practice. Before going down in Week 5, his touches were limited as he shared the backfield with Marks. He averages 10.4 carries per game and just 2.7 yards per carry behind an inconsistent Houston offensive line. He now looks to return in grand fashion against one of the worst run defenses in the NFL.
The Colts rank 29th of 32 against the run, conceding 131.1 rushing yards per game. Backs are averaging a whopping 4.8 yards per carry, and opponents have scored 10 rushing TDs through 10 games. Indianapolis has been especially poor recently, allowing 146.7 rushing yards per game over its last three contests, even with just 78 allowed last week against Miami. Even with Montgomery’s early struggles in mind, the Colts’ run defense is too poor to ignore a lead back in this spot.
Seth McGowan, IND/RB ($4,600)
Our lone Colts player in Thursday’s lineup is rookie RB Seth McGowan, who has recently stepped into a bigger role in the offense. Even with lead back Jonathan Taylor unexpectedly remaining on the team past the trade deadline, Indianapolis may still plan to move him in the offseason and appears to be managing his workload as a result. McGowan now sees steady volume and should continue to as the season progresses. At just $4,600, he is a perfect budget option for fitting in other large salary pieces.
McGowan has logged 18 carries over the past two weeks and has been extremely efficient at 6.8 yards per carry in that span. He has a TD in back-to-back weeks and split last week’s red-zone carries evenly with his veteran teammate. Over the last two weeks, he has handled 34.5% of the Colts’ RB touches, and that number should climb week by week. Both RBs have a solid matchup against a Houston defense conceding 102.6 rushing yards per game. The Texans rank 24th in the league and have allowed 12 rushing TDs through their first nine games.
Xavier Hutchinson, HOU/WR ($6,200)
Texans veteran WR Xavier Hutchinson has stepped into a bigger role with the recent injuries in the WR room and should continue to produce alongside his star teammates on Thursday. With both Marvin Harrison Jr. and Jaylin Noel continuing to miss time, Hutchinson will serve as a primary target for one of the best passing teams in the league. The 26-year-old comes in fresh off one of his strongest performances of the season, catching 4 of 9 targets for 58 yards and a TD. He has scored in three straight games and has been one of Stroud’s most reliable red-zone targets this season.
He will have a more prominent role than he did against the Colts the first time around, when he had 3 receptions for 51 yards against this secondary. He has become Houston’s No. 2 route runner amid the injuries, logging a 73% or higher route participation rate in each of the last three games with 20 targets in that span. Last week’s 9 targets were a season high for the former 2023 draft pick, and the primary slot WR should continue to see steady volume.
Texans D/ST ($5,800)
While the Texans defense is nowhere near where many expected it to be after dominating last season, Thursday is a perfect spot to regain some confidence against one of the worst offenses in the league. Houston’s pass rush has been the story all season and could have one of its most dominant performances against a Colts offensive line decimated by injuries. The Texans rank second in the league with 33 sacks and will try to get to QB Daniel Jones, who has been taken down 2.5 times per game. They got to him four times in the first meeting between these squads and also forced an INT from the mistake-prone QB.
Jones will be without both of his starting tackles, giving Houston a real chance to add to its nine takeaways this season. The Colts enter Thursday averaging the third-most turnovers per game (1.9) and rank second-to-last in yards per play (4.5) through 10 games. Indianapolis got rid of most of its outside playmakers at the deadline and already has the 30th-ranked pass offense, throwing for just 166.7 air yards per game. With Houston such a big favorite on the spread, a dominant showing from the defense is likely.
Nico Collins, HOU/WR ($10,200)
We round out our Thursday night lineup with Texans star WR Nico Collins. We are pairing Stroud with his favorite target, who arrives after his strongest performance of the season. Collins caught nine of a season-high 16 targets for 94 yards and a TD in the narrow loss to the Browns on Sunday. He leads the team with an 18.1% target share and should continue to see the bulk of the looks with the other WRs we touched on out going forward. The 27-year-old was unavailable against the Colts in the first meeting but is ready to take on a division rival he has had success against in the past.
Over his last four games against Indianapolis, Collins is averaging 6.8 receptions and 139.0 receiving yards, with 98-plus yards in each contest. With the Colts’ defensive back injuries, no true number one corner will shadow Collins all night, which could lead to a second consecutive high-volume day. The former Michigan standout is averaging 19.5 yards per reception or higher in each of his last four games against his AFC South rivals, and another highly efficient night is likely with his team such a heavy favorite.
Photo Credit: REUTERS





