To Top

2026 MLS Cup Playoffs Preview: Odds, Picks and Predictions

Every team’s seed, odds to win the MLS Cup and reach the final, plus predictions for the 2026 MLS Playoffs — East and West, all in one place.
Thomas Müller
Phil West Avatar
8 mins read
Share Share
Copy link Share on X Share on Facebook Share on Reddit Share via Email

Looking at the 18 teams playing in the 2026 MLS playoffs, one team in particular stands out. Nashville SC set the single-season points record, on the strength of going unbeaten in its home matches, and finishing with an astonishing goal differential of 46. 

But in the past eight years, which includes two other teams setting points records, only one team has won the Supporters’ Shield (for best regular-season finish) and then gone on to win MLS Cup.

A legitimate MLS Cup-winning case can be made for at least half the field just based on records, star players, and intangibles, and even teams further down the table have the wherewithal to make runs. 

Let’s take a look at the teams. 

Eastern Conference 

Team Seed Points MLS Cup Odds To Reach Final
Nashville SC 1 77 +400 +200
Nashville SC (No. 1 seed, 77 points): It’s no fluke that Nashville’s here. The team’s locked up MLS Defender of the Year (with all three finalists playing for Nashville), has the likely Goalkeeper of the Year winner in Brian Schwake, a front line that features MVP candidate Hany Mukhtar, All-Star Sam Surridge (who scored 21 goals this season), and dynamic winger Cristian Espinoza.
Inter Miami CF 2 60 +450 +200
Inter Miami CF (No. 2 seed, 60 points): They might have a flawed lineup that let in 59 goals over the course of the season, but they also have Lionel Messi, who continued his greatness with a 26-goal, 17-assist season that should land him his third straight MLS MVP award, pacing the Herons to a league-leading 80 goals. They’re also the defending champions.
New England Revolution 3 58 +1400 +700
New England Revolution (No. 3 seed, 58 points): While their point total suggests a good season, and while they’ve got two excellent anchors in goalkeeper Matt Turner and creative midfielder Carles Gil, they’ve got a tough road to just to get to the Eastern Conference finals, needing to dispatch a red-hot Union and then most likely Miami if they can get that far.
Chicago Fire FC 4 55 +1400 +750
Chicago Fire FC (No. 4 seed, 55 points): The revival in Chicago under former U.S. men’s national team head coach Gregg Berhalter continues, with Robert Lewandowski the new focal point of the offense replacing Monterrey-bound Hugo Cuypers in the summer. The 21-year-old South African star-in-the-making Mbekezeli Mbokazi, who featured in the World Cup, anchors the defense.
Charlotte FC 5 54 +2500 +1400
Charlotte FC (No. 5 seed, 54 points): Pep Biel justified his All-Star selection by leading the league with 18 assists and adding 13 goals for an impressive career year. Allan Saint-Maximin was an inspired midseason addition to make a perennial playoff qualifier an intriguing dark horse pick.
Philadelphia Union 6 50 +2500 +1400
Philadelphia Union (No. 6 seed, 50 points): The Union, Supporters’ Shield winners in 2025, got off to a wretched start in 2026, replaced beleaguered coach Bradley Carnell at the World Cup break after notching just seven points in the first 15 matches. The Union replaced him with interim head coach Ryan Richter, who gave wunderkinds Cavan Sullivan and Neil Pierre more minutes, and rocketed them into the playoffs. Coupled with LAFC, they might be the most fearsome 6-seed MLS has had in years.
Columbus Crew 7 47 +6500 +3500
Columbus Crew (No. 7 seed, 47 points): It’s been a weird year for the Crew, who had to grapple back with a season-ending six-match win streak to fight its way into the playoffs. Summer acquisitions Gonzalo Tapia, Brais Méndez, and Santi Rodríguez are making the Crew more interesting compared to earlier in the season, where their league form was mediocre but they still did enough to get to the U.S. Open Cup final.
Orlando City 8 46 +8000 +5000
Orlando City (No. 8 seed/play-in host, 46 points): Two things can be true. Orlando City features a dynamic, exciting offense led by Antoine Griezmann, who had 22 goal contributions in 18 games to lead the Lions’ second-half surge. Orlando City also features one of the worst defenses in MLS history, having given up 78 goals this season, which typically dooms a team to the worst record in the league if it’s close to that vicinity. It all adds up to Orlando hosting the play-in game.
FC Cincinnati 9 46 +6500 +4000
FC Cincinnati (No. 9 seed/play-in visitor, 46 points): Any team with Evander on it (14 goals, 17 assists in 2026) will be formidable, and Kévin Denkey (17 goals, five assists) is a good partner on paper even if it didn’t always manifest on the field. If FCC gets past Orlando, which could happen, the team will face Nashville, who it lost to 2-0 on Decision Day. But Cincy upsetting Nashville in the playoffs is a distinct possibility.

Western Conference 

Team Seed Points MLS Cup Odds To Reach Final
Vancouver Whitecaps FC 1 64 +450 +175
Vancouver Whitecaps FC (No. 1 seed, 64 points): While they’re not quite what they were at the start of the season, having moved key midfielder Sebastian Berhalter to England, Ryan Gauld is fully back from injury, and that’s helped MLS’ most dynamic, fun-to-watch team stay fleet of foot on the ball.
FC Dallas 2 58 +1400 +600
FC Dallas (No. 2 seed, 58 points): Croatian international Petar Musa stayed the whole season, despite thoughts he’d move in the summer to a European club, and his 22 goals on the season, second only to Messi, have done much to lock them into this lofty spot in the table.
St. Louis City SC 3 54 +1600 +700
St. Louis City SC (No. 3 seed, 54 points): MLS Coach of the Year finalist Yoann Damet has led an incredible turnaround from 2025, when St. Louis was one of the worst teams in the West — and that’s despite losing two key players mid-season, though he did also bring in reliable striker Rafael Navarro from Colorado in that window.
San Jose Earthquakes 4 52 +1800 +700
San Jose Earthquakes (No. 4 seed, 52 points): Thanks to a hot and somewhat surprising start, San Jose got into playoff position winning nine of its first 10 matches. Despite winning only five more matches in the remaining 24, the Quakes did enough to stay up — adding to the legend of coach Bruce Arena, who still gets MLS better than the majority of coaches in the league.
Houston Dynamo FC 5 51 +1600 +650
Houston Dynamo FC (No. 5 seed, 51 points): MLS Newcomer of the Year finalist Guilherme had an outstanding debut season, scoring 16 goals and adding 10 assists — with goal contributions adding up to more than 60% of the Dynamo’s modest output. But they also had a stingy enough defense to make the formula work.
LAFC 6 47 +2000 +750
LAFC (No. 6 seed, 47 points): It’s been an unusual season for LAFC, which saw head coach Marc dos Santos dismissed in September after a surprising slump set his team back in the playoff race. They are, like the Union in the East, a dangerous six-seed, with Son Heung-min and Denis Bouanga still potent in front of goal.
Portland Timbers FC 7 46 +6500 +3000
Portland Timbers FC (No. 7 seed, 46 points): Though they looked to be on the brink of playoff elimination, the Timbers won four straight matches to qualify for the playoffs and somehow avoid the play-in match. Kristoffer Velde led the way with 12 goals and 10 assists — for another team that made a midseason coaching change that paid off with a postseason trip.
Seattle Sounders FC 8 46 +10000 +4000
Seattle Sounders FC (No. 8 seed/play-in host, 46 points): It was a strange year for the Sounders, who appeared for a stretch as if they wouldn’t make the playoffs, casting doubt on Brian Schmetzer’s standing as MLS’ longest-tenured head coach. But a midseason move to bring in Dejan Joveljić helped right the perennial powers, and assuming a play-in match win, sets them up for a Cascadia first-round series against their neighbors to the north.
Real Salt Lake 9 45 +10000 +4000
Real Salt Lake (No. 9 seed/play-in visitor, 45 points): RSL somehow weathered losing its two best players midway through the season — Diego Luna to nagging injuries, and Zavier Gozo to a high-profile Crystal Palace move — and hung on with its typical late-season tenacity, finishing 5-2-1 in its last eight matches to snag the West’s final playoff spot.

🗞️ Storylines to Watch

A More Perfect Union

Since making its midseason changes, the Union have been outstanding, averaging 2.26 points per game — the very clip that Nashville played at all season. Look for them to oust the Revs and upset Messi and Co. on the way to the conference final, giving Nashville all they can handle before finally bowing out. They 

Can St. Louis Surprise?

St. Louis plays organized, tough, team-oriented soccer, and had they drawn a Portland or a Houston in the first round, they’d likely go into the second round with momentum. As it played out, however, City ended up against LAFC, after splitting a season series that was done by May — well before what they’ve both evolved into now. Both teams enjoy raucous home support, meaning it should be an action-packed series going the full three matches to decide a winner. But look for St. Louis to emerge and land in the conference finals after what should be a more manageable second round. 

Messi Making His Mark

Barring a surprise in the voting, Messi will head in these playoffs a three-time MVP, and will certainly get his goals and assists in an opening series against the Crew and then what we’re predicting to be their eventual exit against the Union. But Messi’s matches will be full of scoring and he’ll be at the center of it.

Believe in Brian White

If you’re looking for a playoff goalscoring leader, Messi seems the reflexive pick, but Vancouver’s Brian White may actually emerge on top when MLS Cup concludes. The Whitecaps’ goals come from all over — the team had 18 different scorers in 2026 — but White is far and away the leader with 20 goals, getting service from multiple wide players on a team that excels at placing key passes.

🏆 MLS Cup Playoffs Pick: Vancouver Whitecaps

While it doesn’t always work out this way in MLS, look for the No. 1 seeds from both conferences to advance to MLS Cup in Nashville. Both the Whitecaps and the Yotes are clearly the cream of their respective conferences, and despite what St. Louis and Philly will throw at them in the conference finals, both conference champs will find their way to the final and look good doing it. 

While this sets up for Nashville to do the rare Supporters’ Shield and MLS Cup double, Vancouver has a couple of things that Nashville does not — primarily, having been to the final last year, and coming closer to defeating Miami than many remember. (The ‘Caps missed out on taking a second-half lead with an Emmanuel Sabbi shot that hit posts and then bounced out – back to Sabbi, who hit the post on the follow-up shot. Miami got its match winner several minutes later.) 

Vancouver also has an X factor in Thomas Müller — a veteran leader who has won a World Cup and Champions League title, playing multiple high-stakes game in his impressive career. While Nashville is a good team coming off a 2025 U.S. Open Cup victory and a historic 2026 season, they don’t have a player that’s been as battle-tested as Müller. After missing out on a chance to add an MLS Cup win to his tally last year, he could be the difference maker in what promises to be a fun final that could come down to penalty kicks.

About the Author
VIEW ALL POSTS

Phil West is a writer based in Austin, Texas. His work has appeared in MLSSoccer.com, Backheeled and Howler, and in major publications such as the Los Angeles Times, Seattle Times, Austin Chronicle and San Antonio Express-News. He wrote two books on soccer for The Overlook Press. At Lineups he covers soccer, the World Cup and prediction markets.

VIEW ALL POSTS