Best Bet: HALL +4.5 (-110) at FanDuel
Score Prediction: Wisconsin 71, Seton Hall 69
The Pick: Wisconsin 71, Seton Hall 69
We’ll take the Seton Hall spread based on various data points supporting the Pirates while also playing into Wisconsin’s 2026 ATS struggles.
Game Betting Analysis
This one is tricky, but we’re going with Seton Hall to cover the spread. The total indicates an Under play, though, both teams 1-3 to the Under through four games this season. However, the Badgers have seen 142 total points or more in nine of 10 non-conference neutral court games, so there’s friction in the data. For the spread, Wisconsin is struggling with a 1-3 ATS mark this season while Seton Hall is 3-1 including a cover against Alabama on the road. Seton Hall is now 10-5 ATS over its last 15 non-conference games along with a perfect 5-0 ATS mark in its last five games on a neutral court and a remarkable 10-3 ATS mark in 13 games as an underdog.
Seton Hall-Wisconsin Odds (Spread, Moneyline, Over/Under)
Deciding Factor: Wisconsin’s Suddenly Explosive Offense vs. Seton Hall’s Turnover-Forcing Defense
Wisconsin looked shaky out of the gate but has turned a corner at just the right time heading into the Baha Mar Championship. The Badgers are 4-0 after Sunday’s 89-81 comeback win over Coastal Carolina, a game in which Owen Foxwell exploded for 33 points — 27 of them in the second half on 6-of-10 shooting and a perfect 14-of-14 from the line — igniting a 13-2 run alongside back-to-back threes with Eian Elmer that erased a double-digit deficit. Nolan Winter, who’d struggled to find his footing early in the season (he called it a “shaky start” after a rough outing against Fairfield), bounced back with 9 rebounds, 7 of them offensive, and coach Greg Gard has been pushing him to stay aggressive. That kind of offensive balance matters against a Seton Hall team that is still breaking in 13 new roster faces of its own, and Wisconsin brings a 23-game nonconference home winning streak worth of momentum and depth (Braeden Carrington and Austin Rapp both chipped in double-digit efforts Sunday) into a neutral-site setting that should otherwise favor the Big Ten side less.
Seton Hall, meanwhile, might be the single toughest defensive out at this event. The Pirates (3-1) are allowing just 61.5 points per game and have forced at least seven steals in every outing this season, a defensive identity that nearly knocked off No. 18 Alabama on the road — Seton Hall trailed by 17 in the second half before cutting it to three, despite playing what the team described as “flu-ridden” and missing a key piece in Coleman. Freshman Ilay Dolinski provided a spark off the bench in that game with 15 points on 6-of-7 shooting, while Devin Williams added a double-double stat line with 7 boards and 4 blocks, and Roddie Anderson III leads a still-developing offense at just 13.2 points per game. Seton Hall ranks 300th nationally in adjusted tempo, a deliberate, grind-it-out pace that kept Alabama’s usual scoring well below normal, and that same approach is exactly the kind of matchup that could disrupt a Wisconsin team that just found its rhythm in an up-and-down shootout. If the Pirates’ defense can force the Badgers into the same kind of turnover-heavy, half-court possessions that frustrated Alabama, Seton Hall has a real path to the upset in Nassau even while its own offense is still finding its footing.
Game Information
- Date: Thursday, November 19, 2026
- Kickoff: 8:30 p.m. (ET)
- Network: CBSSN
- Location: Nassau, Bahamas
- Venue: Baha Mar Convention Center – n/a
College Basketball Game Trends & Odds
Key Players
Seton Hall Pirates
- Elijah Fisher — Last Game: 14 points, 5 rebounds
- Ilay Dolinski — Last Game: 20 points
Wisconsin Badgers
- Owen Foxwell — Last Game: 33 points, 6 assists
- Nolan Winter — Last Game: 14 points, 9 rebounds
Photo Credit: REUTERS